I had some feedback on my haul post requesting for an in-depth review for the Sailor Moon eyeliner. I decided to wait a while so I could have time to use the eyeliner a few times before writing about it!
I bought mine from YesStyle for $33 CAD. It might seem quite pricey for a liquid eyeliner, but it's roughly around the same price as some of the liners you find at Sephora.
The eyeliner comes with 2 lids, one standard pink lid, and then the Sailor Moon wand tip which fits on top of the pink lid.
Creer Beaute made the Sailor Moon eyeliner waterproof with a brush style tip. (Packaging also claims it can write as fine as 0.1mm)
I'm a fan of liquid eyeliners as you can tell. Both the Koji Dolly Wink and the Sailor Moon eyeliner have brush tips, while the Stila Stay All Day is a felt tip.
Excuse the white tissue, I don't have a white desk or counter to use, and it's hard to show the eye liner tips on a black-brown top. Size wise, without the Sailor Moon wand topper the eyeliner is the same size as the Koji Dolly Wink and Stila Stay All Day.
Comparing different eyeliner widths. If you're very careful you can draw a really fine line with the Sailor Moon eyeliner. (I'm not sure if it's precisely 0,1mm but it's pretty fine!)
I smudged all 3 eyeliners before letting it dry completely. All 3 liners claim to be waterproof, even the Sailor Moon one! But I recommend not rubbing your eyes until you've let it dry first.
I haven't had any problems with it smudging onto my eyelids throughout the day or smearing off from sweat/tears. I have quite teary eyes (not from crying just sensitive and teary/watery eyes) and this eyeliner has managed to stay on my lids :)
P.S. I have heard some reviews about the eyeliner pen drying out too quickly, I'm not sure how quickly it dries out as my pen is still quite wet.
Till next time!